Home About Us Contact Us

Official Journals By StatPerson Publication

Table of Content - Volume 6 Issue 3 -June 2018


 

 

 

Study of pulmonary function tests in tobacco factory workers

 

Gajanan V Patil1, Atish Pagar2*, U S Patil3, M K Parekh4

 

1Student, 2Associate Professor, 3Professor, 4Professor and HOD, Department of Physiology, Bharati Vidyapeeth (Deemed to be University), Medical College and Hospital, Sangli, Maharashtra, INDIA.

Email: abp123098@gmail.com, patil.gajanan25@gmail.com, mkparekh999@gmail.com

 

Abstract               Tobacco use is a risk factor for many diseases, especially those affecting the heartliver, and lungs, as well as many cancers. In 2008, the World Health Organization named tobacco as the world's single greatest cause of preventable death. Workers in the tobacco industry may experience exposure to certain environmental hazards, including tobacco leaf dust and pesticides remaining on tobacco as residues from field or post harvesting applications. As per tobacco institute of India 3.5 million people involved in tobacco industry which includes 6 million farmers, 20 million farm workers, 4.4 million beedi workers, 2.2 million tendu leaf pluckers and 2 million traders although the trade unions and private organizations says that the actual number of Tobacco workers is much higher as there are many unregistered workers in India.4 The dust of tobacco enters the respiratory system of tobacco factory workers through inhalation during tobacco processing, causes respiratory impairments.5 Workers of tobacco industries are chronically and predominantly exposed to tobacco dust and majority of workers of tobacco industries are smokers and Non-smoker tobacco workers are also exposed to passive smoking at their work places.6 In present study it was found that exposed workers show values of FEV1 lower than their predicted values and also there is statistically significant difference between exposed and unexposed subjects. FVC values in workers are found decreased and is statistically significant. Statistically significantly decreased values of PEFR are observed in tobacco workers. Significantly decreased FEV1/FVC ratio is also observed in tobacco workers. Decrease in FEV1 and PEFR shows obstructive changes in large airways.11

Keywords: Pulmonary function test. Probability value, Peak expiratory flow rate.

 

 

 

INTRODUCTION

Tobacco is a product prepared from the leaves of the tobacco plant by crushing them. The plant is part of the genus Nicotiana and of the Solanaceae (nightshade) family. While more than 70 species of tobacco are known, the chief commercial crop is N. tabacum. The more potent variant N. rustica is also used around the world.1 Tobacco contains the alkaloid nicotine, which is a stimulant. Dried tobacco leaves are mainly used for smoking in cigarettescigarspipe tobacco, and flavoured shisha tobacco. They can be also consumed as snuff or tobacco. Tobacco use is a risk factor for many diseases, especially those affecting the heartliver, and lungs, as well as many cancers. In 2008, the World Health Organization named tobacco as the world's single greatest cause of preventable death. Workers in the tobacco industry may experience exposure to certain environmental hazards, including tobacco leaf dusts and pesticides remaining on tobacco as residues from field or post harvesting applications. Furthermore, exposure to asbestos should be considered since this material could have been extensively used as insulation in the heating system for drying processes 2. Tobacco use contributes to chronic diseases and health problems including cancers, cardiovascular diseases, strokes, tuberculosis, respiratory diseases, gastrointestinal disorders, cancer in oral cavity, reduced physical fitness, increased risk of osteoporosis and broken bones, cataracts, blindness, and increased time needed to recover from illness. Cigarette smoking and tobacco uses also lead to the alteration of the lipoprotein levels.1

 

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The study was conducted on the Tobacco factory workers at, Jaysingpur Tal:-Shirol, Dist:-Kolhapur, during the year 2015-2016. Study was done on 114 Subjects. The age group was from 20-55 yrs. who were exposed to tobacco more than one year. Controls were selected from the office workers in the factory areas and other persons who were not exposed to the tobacco at the factory. A modified questionnaire was prepared with the general information about the workers i.e. name, age, sex, height, weight, education, marital status, years of working experience and health problems. Prior to the pulmonary function test the questionnaire was explained. Informed consent was taken from each subject. The pulmonary function tests were performed using computerized spirometer (Clarity- Clarity medical Pvt. Ltd. Indi, India) in sitting position. Height of subjects and control was measured with the help of measuring tape. Weight was recorded with weighing machine. The data of subjects like name, age, sex, working experience, height, weight, date of performing test etc. was fed to the computerized spirometer. Screening of subjects was done with proforma.

Procedure: Careful examination of the workers was done. Workers with cardiovascular or respiratory illness, smokers and drinker were excluded. The tests were performed in sitting position. The subjects were familiarized with the set up details and demonstrations were given to our satisfaction. The subjects were made to breathe forcefully following deep inspiration in to the mouth piece attached to the spirometer. Expiration was maintained for a minimum period of 3-4 seconds. 3 trials of maximal inspiratory and expiratory efforts were made and only highest reading was taken for data processing.


 

OBSERVATIONS AND RESULTS

Table 1: General information of workers

Characteristics

No. Of Workers

 

%

A. Age group (Years)

 

 

 

20-30

06

 

10.5

31-40

15

 

26.3

41-50

16

 

28

51-55

20

 

35

B. Total working period

 

 

 

1-4 years

08

 

14.00

5-10 years

20

 

35. 00

More than11years

29

 

50. 08

C. work duration

 

 

 

Annual

57

 

100

Seasonal

00

 

0

D. Educational qualification

 

 

 

Illiterate

36

 

63.1

Primary

18

 

31.5

Higher

02

 

3.5

Graduate

01

 

1.7

E. Category according to BMI

 

 

 

overweight(25-29.9)

09

 

15.7

obese (>_30)

01

 

1.7

Normal (18.5 -24.5)

33

 

57.8

Underweight (<18.5)

14

 

24.5

Table 2: Pulmonary function tests in control group and tobacco workers showing mean value and standard deviation

Parameter

Study Groups

Z Test

P Value

Control

Workers

Mean

SD

Mean

SD

FVC (L)

4.06

0.65

3.17

0.43

-8.642

0.00**

FEV1 (L)

3.79

0.59

2.92

0.35

-9.72

0.00**

PEFR (L/MIN.)

4.38

0.89

3.12

0.46

-9.42

0.00**

FEV1/FVC%

89.68

4.77

81.53

3.70

103.89

0.00*

** highly significant * Significant

Table 3: Showing Mean value and standard deviation of forced expiratory volume at the end of one second (FEV1) in tobacco factory workers according to duration of exposure

Yrs of Exposure.

Mean

Sd

N=57

F Value

P Value

1-4 YRS

3.27

0.32

8

 

6.169

 

0.003**

5-10YRS

2.88

0.31

20

more than 11 yrs.

2.84

0.31

29

**highly significant *significant

 

Table 4: Showing Mean value and standard deviation of forced vital capacity (FVC) tobacco factory workers according to duration of exposure

Yrs. of Exposure.

Mean

Sd

No. of Workers

N=57

F Value

P Value

1-4 YRS

3.4

0.29

8

1.589

0.213

5-10YRS

3.18

0.35

20

more than 11 years

3.13

0.49

29

**highly significant *significant

Table 5: Showing Mean value and standard deviation of Peak expiratory flow rate (PEFR) in tobacco factory workers according to duration of exposure

Yrs. of Exposure.

Mean

Sd

No. of Workers

N=57

F Value

P Value

1-4 YRS

3.56

0.46

8

 

5.292

 

 

0.007**

5-10YRS

3.09

0.43

20

more than 11 years

3.02

0.4

29

** highly significant *significant

 

Table 6: Showing mean value and standard deviation of forced expiratory volume at the end of one second and forced vital capacity (%FEV1/FVC) with duration of exposure of tobacco factory workers

Yrs. of Exposure.

Mean

Sd

No. of Workers

N=57

F Value

P Value

1-4 YRS

82.35

0.33

8

 

588.73

0.00**

5-10YRS

74.81

0.63

20

more than 11 years

77.99

0.51

29

**highly significant *significant

RESULTS

Table. No.1.shows percentage of workers according to age group where 10.5% workers are of age between 20-30 yrs., 26.3% workers are of age between 31-40 yrs., 28% workers are of age between 41-50years and 35% workers are of between 51-55 years. Percentage of workers according to the exposure shows 14% workers are between 0-4 years of exposure. 35% workers are exposed for 5-10 years. 08% workers are having experience of more than 11 years. According to literacy 63.1% workers are illiterate. 31.5% workers are having primary education. 3.5% workers having higher education and only 1.7% workers are graduate. This shows that majority of workers are iiliterate. Table no. 2 and graph no. 1 and 2 shows forced expiratory volume at the end of one second (FEV1) in control group was 3.79 L and in tobacco workers is 2.92 L. The difference is statistically highly significant (P=0.00). Huuskonen M.S. et al (1984) Mukhtar MS et al (1991) also found the reduction in FEV1.7, 9 Forced vital capacity (FVC) in control group was 4.06 L and in tobacco factory workers 3.17 L. The difference is statistically highly significant (P=0.000). Huuskonen M.S. et al (1984) also found reduction in force vital capacity (FVC).7 Peak expiratory flow rate (PEFR) in control group was 4.38 L/min. and that of tobacco workers was 3.12 L/min. which is statistically highly significant (P=0.00). Mukhtar MS et al (1991), Ahmet Tevfik et al (2001) also found the reduction in PEFR9,11 %FEV1/FVC in control group was 89.68 % and in tobacco workers 81.53%. The difference is statistically significant. (P=0.00). Ahmet Tevfik et al (2001) also found the reduction in %FEV1/FVC. Our findings are in correlation with other findings.1114,17,21 As seen in table no.3 and graph no.3 after 5 to 11 years of exposure forced expiratory volume at the end of one second (FEV1) is progressively decreased, and this decrease is statistically significant. (P=0.003). Our findings are in correlation with other studies, who found the positive correlation of FEV1 and the exposure.1,17,21,27. As seen in table no.4 and graph no.4 after 5 to 11 years of exposure forced vital capacity (FVC) among the subjects was seen to be decreased. But is statistically not significant (P=0.213). As seen in table no.5 and graph no.5 after 5 to 11 years of exposure peak expiratory flow rate (PEFR) of workers was seen to be progressively decreased. And is statistically significant. (P=0.007). As seen in table no.6 and graph no.6 after 5 to 11 years of exposure the percentage of forced expiratory volume at the end of one second and forced vital capacity (%FEV1/FVC) of workers was seen to be decreased and is statistically significant (P=0.00).

 

DISCUSSION

In this study the results show that the exposure to tobacco dust may affect the pulmonary functions. A decrease in FVC shows restrictive changes in the airways. While FEV1 and PEFR show obstructive changes in large airways. So we can say that long term exposure to the tobacco environment causes mixed type of lung diseases. Exposure to tobacco dust has been suggested to affect the respiratory system. A tendency towards the lower spirometric values among the tobacco workers has been suspected in several studies. Mukhtar s. Et al (1991) have shown decreased ventilator capacity values in tobacco factory workers particularly in small airways.9 Kjaergaard et al (1989) reported significantly decreased FVC and FEV1 in tobacco factory workers compared to referents.8 Huuskonen et al (1984) reported restrictive and obstructive changes especially in small airways of tobacco workers and a decrease in diffusion capacity.7 A decrease in FVC shows restrictive changes in the airways. While FEV1 and PEFR shows obstructive changes in large airways. So we can say that long term exposure to the tobacco environment causes mixed type of lung diseases.

 

CONCLUSION

It may be stated that the lung function capacity is significantly decreased in the tobacco workers than that of the controls. It is due to long term exposure to tobacco dust.

 

REFERENCES

    • Fahmida Khatun, M. Kamruzzaman, Mominul Islam, Shofikul Islam, Hafizur Rahman, Rezaul Karim Health hazards and the socioeconomic status of female labour of tobacco processing mills in Kushtia, Bangladesh. Science Journal of Public Health 2013; 1(1):1-8
    • Huuskonen MS; Järvisalo J; Koskinen H; Kivistö H Serum angiotensin-converting enzyme and lysosomal enzymes in tobacco workers. Chest 1986 89(2) 224-228
    • Kouser Banu K, Sitalakshmi R and Padmavathi R.Pulmonary Functions among Beedi Rolling Workers of South India -ss journal doi 10-7439/ijbar ISSN 2229-3809
    • BP ChattopadhyayS KunduA MahataSK Jane AlamA study to assess the respiratory impairments among the male beedi workers in unorganized sectors.2006 vol.10(2) 69-73
    • Dr. Nasrin Sultana Dr. Md. AbulKhair Basher Occupational Hazards in Tobacco Factory workers experience from Rangpur.Banglavision research journal 2015 vol.15 (1) 81-90.
    • M S Huuskonen,' K Husman, J Jarvisalo,' O Korhonen,' M Kotimaa,' T Kuusela,' H Nordman,' A Zitting,' and R Mantyjarv. Extrinsic allergic alveolitis in the tobacco industry. British Journal of Industrial Medicine 1984;41 :77-83
    • Kjaergaard SK, Pedersen OF, Dust exposure, eye redness, eye cytology and mucus membrane irritation in a tobacco industry. Int.arch occup environ health 1989; 61(8) 519-25.
    • Mukhtar MS,R. GM, Gamra NS,Afan AM, Zendah MI, respiratory effects of occupational exposure to tobacco dust.respiration 1991.58(5-6) 271-76.
    • Erik Juel Jensen, Bente Pedersen, Ruben Frederiksen, Ronald Dahl. Prospective study on the effect of smoking and nicotine substitution on leucocyte blood counts and relation between blood leucocytes and lung function. Thorax.1998.53.784-789.
    • Ahmet Ttevfik S.Nter1 Faruk Baúirici2 Cihad D.Ndar1 Abdullah Marangoz2 Yildaz Peksen, lung functions in workers exposed to tobacco dust. turk j med sci 31 (2001) 143-146.
    • Jadranka Mustajbegovic, Eugenija Zuskin, E.Neil Schachter,Josipa Kern, Marijana Luburic-Milas and Jasna Pucarin. Respiratory findings in tobacco workers. Occupational and environmental lung disease 2001 -1740-1748.